Houston Symphony Orchestra’s opening night presented America three ways with a slice of sophisticated Russia. From the American national anthem to An American in Paris and back to New York City for West Side Story with Joshua Bell, Stravinksy’s L’oiseau de feu stuck out as the most remarkable piece on the program.
Playing Suite for Violin and Orchestra from West Side Story, an arrangement of Leonard Bernstein’s musical by William David Brohn, Bell was confident but underwhelming – a disappointment due to the choice of repertoire. Brohn’s arrangement re-imagines West Side Story as a tone poem. It sounds like a hit compilation of favorites, songs like “I feel pretty” and “Maria” cut and glued together as a light medley. The construction is hummable until Bell’s cadenza hits three-quarters of the way through – a wild flourish he composed. But even before the cadenza, a truly impressive show of sheer skill indeed, the violin solo falls out of place from the breezy orchestra. A slew of double stops and finger-flying runs sits heavy against Bernstein’s original style, as if an old Romantic has come and crashed the party.
This was Bell’s first time performing with music director and conductor Andrés Orozco-Estrada, and their collaboration on stage felt easy, even charming. Orozco-Estrada, still bending and weaving from Gershwin’s An American in Paris, caught the spirit of Bernstein, even though Brohn’s arrangement did not. It seems to be a Houston tradition to begin opening night with the Star-Spangled Banner. Gershwin, first on the program, followed the anthem with panache. The beeps and bops leapt from the stage; the softer, slower sections struck a silvery timbre. But as the opening piece of the symphony’s 102nd season, it was perhaps too carefree, too amusing.