How clever of Alexandre Tharaud to open his QEH concert with Schubert’s Moments musicaux, salon pieces which combine charm and tenderness with an unsettling edginess to create Schubert’s emotional and musical landscape in microcosm. From the opening notes of the first of the suite, Tharaud imbued the music with intimacy and set the tone for the whole evening, even in the more extrovert sentences of Ravel’s “Alborada del gracioso” from Miroirs. This was piano playing which encouraged concentrated listening.
The Schubert was rich in song-lines, unexpected highlighting of interior melodies and bass details, and a delicacy of touch and sound which had us leaning in more closely to listen to every detail. Even in the more agitated and declamatory movements (4 and 5), Tharaud never lost sight of the intrinsic character of Schubert’s writing.
With our attention fully engaged and curious for more, he then played his own transcription of the Adagietto from Mahler’s Symphony no. 5 in C sharp minor. Perhaps because the great theme has become synonymous with Visconti’s film Death in Venice, the piano transcription had a filmic quality, and could quite easily have been taken for a soundtrack if one didn’t know the original from which it sprang. Tharaud is following in a great tradition of appropriating orchestral music for the piano – from Liszt’s Beethoven symphonies onwards – and his transcription is faithful to the original with the addition of details, in particular judicious use of the pedal, when the texture and emotion of the music demands it. The grand sweep of the original was there, but somehow this version did not wholly convince, though nonetheless sensitively played.