ENFRDEES
La web de música clásica

A majestic meditation on justice and compassion: Handel’s Solomon at the Elbphilharmonie

Por , 16 mayo 2025

Handel’s Solomon, one of the central productions at this year’s Göttingen Handel Festival, received its premiere at Hamburg’s Elbphilharmonie. Under George Petrou, the FestspielOrchester Göttingen and NDR Vokalensemble shaped an ideal of wise and harmonious rule. With a refined cast, the performance built a world of clarity and persuasion. In an age where such ideals feel remote, this emotionally sincere evening left a quietly powerful impression.

Lena Sutor-Wernich
© Alciro Theodoro Da Silva

As a reputed Handel interpreter, Petrou set a noble, steady pace from the very beginning, letting Handel’s orchestration – horns, winds and divided strings – resound with clarity and weight. Across nearly three hours, he sustained both structural poise and vivid dramatic tension, shaping each scene with alertness to Handel’s brilliant emotion building. With too many striking moments to count, Solomon emerged as a living gallery of emotional display and theatrical detail.

In the role of Solomon, Lena Sutor-Wernich struck a remarkable balance between authoritative command and deeply human warmth. Her voice – centered, focused and tinged with a mature, rounded timbre – projected the wisdom and self-possession befitting a king already seasoned in rule. This vocal maturity lent credibility to Solomon’s deliberations, imbuing them with both moral gravity and empathetic nuance. The duality of strength and compassion became especially clear in the pivotal Act 2 scene, the famous ‘Judgment of Solomon’. Even when issuing the dramatic order to divide the child, her tone remained judicial rather than theatrical, allowing the surrounding tension and emotion to unfold with organic intensity.

Francesca Lombardi Mazzulli, in the dual roles of the Queen of Sheba and Second Harlot, revealed striking emotional range. As Queen, she exchanged ceremonious lines with Sutor-Wernich’s Solomon, projecting mutual admiration through graceful restraint. In contrast, her portrayal of the pleading mother was raw and immediate, her voice charged with urgency and vulnerability. With subtle vocal shading, she drew two vividly distinct figures, highlighting not only Handel’s dramatic depth, but also her own expressive finesse. 

As Zadok, James Way provided a vital dramatic and musical foil to Solomon’s restraint. His tenor was bright yet pliant, especially in “Sacred raptures cheer my breast”, where he conveyed the spiritual enthusiasm of the priestly order without ever tipping into affectation. Throughout the oratorio, Way’s phrasing brought clarity to the text and buoyancy to the musical line, helping to animate both ceremonial scenes and moral reflection.

The cast of Solomon in Göttingen
© Alciro Theodoro Da Silva

The supporting cast brought distinct colour and purpose to the performance. Carlotta Colombo, as First Harlot, set a pointed contrast to Mazzulli’s vulnerable mother, her bright, cutting tone sharpening the dramatic edges of the Judgment scene. Isaak Lee’s Attendant shaped the narrative flow with clean diction and unobtrusive style, echoing the calm authority established by Sutor-Wernich’s Solomon. As the Levite, Armin Kolarczyk lent ceremonial weight to the oratorio’s outer frame, his firm, grounded presence giving both the prologue and epilogue a quiet sense of gravity.

While Solomon may seem alien from today’s stage – more allegory than action – it also speaks to a persistent human question: how can power be made just, and justice made visible? Handel answers not with argument, but with architecture – of voices, of harmony, of ritual. This Göttingen presentation embraced this architecture fully, not by monumentalising it, but by revealing its intricate inner workings. That clarity, more than any single character or aria, was what made the performance feel both timeless and urgently present. 

****1
Sobre nuestra calificación
Ver la programación
“with a refined cast, the performance built a world of clarity and persuasion”
Crítica hecha desde Elbphilharmonie: Grand Hall, Hamburg el 15 mayo 2025
Handel, Solomon
George Petrou, Dirección
FestspielOrchester Göttingen
NDR Vokalensemble
Lena Sutor-Wernich, Solomon
Francesca Lombardi Mazzulli, Queen of Sheba, Second harlot
James Way, Zadok
Carlotta Colombo, First harlot
Armin Kolarczyk, Levite
Isaak Lee, Tenor
Impactante Carmen en la Temporada Lírica coruñesa
****1
West Side Story de Gustavo Dudamel en el Liceu
*****
Il Giocatore de Jommelli en una producción de corte contemporáneo
***11
El tiempo que nos queda: La traviata en el Teatro Real
***11
Rusalka inunda el Liceu bajo las voces de Grigorian y Beczała
****1
García-Alarcón y Bintou Dembélé: una bella metáfora
****1
Más críticas...