It was an eerie night for music in Alisa Weilerstein’s Wigmore Hall recital; a concert that allowed the listener to hear what Brahms could be if a composer like Stravinsky edited his notes and altered his expressive markings. This was bestial Brahms; the kind that started off each phrase with a brusque and violent, even startling, attack. The execution, with its savage pace and sudden switches in dynamics and tempo, was the kind that may have just been censored in the more traditional, evenly-paced epoch of 19th-century Romanticism.
If Weilerstein’s idiosyncratic style is marked with anything, it’s absolute rejection of conventional performance or cellist stereotype. The first movement of Brahms’ Cello Sonata in E minor, marked Allegro non troppo, dispensed with those long, languorous notes that we tend to associate with it. Each new phrase was played with an attack so laden with vibrato and hot-tempered volume that the note was not so much an introduction as a lunge. Fast speed and dwindling sound in the successive notes meant many of the work’s plaintive and lulling themes were rushed through.
Weilerstein’s experimentation became even more radical in the second movement. Rapid quavers between belligerent attacks became lightly executed staccati, countering the accented notes preceding them. The movement thus began to lose its fluency and split into two polarised divisions: fierce, wolf-like attacks and thin strokes of narrow vibrato whose innocent mood resembled something that came not from Brahms but from The Nutcracker. Weilerstein’s abrupt shifts in both tone and in vibrato made for some tantalising intellectual listening – but also void of sentiment.
The Sonata in F major introduced to us another facet of Weilerstein's inimitable approach to the composer. Here the renowned pizzicato section of the Adagio affettuoso second movement, was neither Adagio in pace nor as tender as affettuoso would imply. Her pizzicati came out as throbbing prods, plucked with an untamed vigour.
Inon Barnatan was apt to counter these sometimes cantankerous chords with a greater ebb and flow applied to his own handling of his piano part. Although his performance lacked the incomparable creativity that his partner’s exuded, Barnatan opened up some of the rallentandi and diminuendi that Weilerstein’s playing eschewed. Much of the time her own volume eclipsed his sound and occasionally the pianist was forced to hurry to catch-up.