ENFRDEES
The classical music website

A dextrous dance: Bartók, Rachmaninov and Dukas from the BBC Symphony at the Proms

Von , 10 August 2025

For its latest Prom, the BBC Symphony Orchestra under conductor Josep Pons gave us an intriguing programme that spoke to the best of what it can do, pairing two ballets, Dukas’ La Péri and Bartok’s The Miraculous Mandarin, separated by Rachmaninov’s Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini. It’s a canny menu with thematic links between the dishes, but plenty of contrasts to highlight the individual flavours of each.

Josep Pons and the BBC Symphony Orchestra
© BBC | Mark Allan

The Dukas -– a Poème dansé – has a certain whimsy to it which reflects its subject: an encounter between Alexander the Great and an Iranian spirit, the Peri. Pons took a spacious and relaxed approach, adopting tempi that allowed the work to breathe without serious detriment to the heady swirl of Dukas’ writing, though there were points, particularly in the second half, where his interpretation felt just a little too polite. Pons kept the orchestral sections in balance, and some particularly fine horn-playing, amber and mellow, gave the piece a certain crepuscular beauty.

The inevitable ‘heave-ho’ preceded the arrival of Beatrice Rana to the piano for the Rachmaninov, in a well-judged reading of the piece which saw both soloist and orchestra in total harmony of approach. Rana’s playing at times elicited the most delicate of sounds, yet still audible – no small feat in the Royal Albert Hall – as she veered between an impressionist blur and pinpoint definition between the notes. It was those light moments, rather than her dynamic fortissimi, that gave the greatest pleasure and demonstrated a quiet virtuosity. The famous eighteenth variation, now so familiar from cheesy romance films, was sketched out in bold colour but didn’t descend into the maudlin, and was the better for it. Pons led his forces in a tightly controlled reading: the attack at the first variation was crisp, the woodwind and particularly plangent bassoons fragrant and clean. A surprising encore, a transcription from The Nutcracker Suite, was terrific fun and further bound together the balletic elements surrounding the Rachmaninov.

Beatrice Rana
© BBC | Mark Allan

After the interval, The Miraculous Mandarin. Bartók is fiendishly tough on the orchestra, with little respite for any of the sections. It speaks to the BBC Symphony Orchestra’s traditional versatility that they were able to tackle the technical demands of the ballet with minimal difficulty; particular credit goes to the brass and woodwind for near-virtuosic playing. Again, Pons kept the band together, giving a sense of controlled chaos in the introduction to the work and a constant sense of drive that prevented any sense of slack in the playing. A fine performance to cap a rewarding programme.

****1
Über unsere Stern-Bewertung
Veranstaltung anzeigen
“a canny menu with thematic links between the dishes, but plenty of contrasts”
Rezensierte Veranstaltung: Royal Albert Hall, London, am 8 August 2025
Dukas, La Péri, poème-dansé
Rachmaninow, Rapsodie über ein Thema von Paganini a-Moll für Klavier und Orchester, Op. 43
Bartók, Der Wunderbare Mandarin, Op.19: Suite
Beatrice Rana, Klavier
Josep Pons, Musikalische Leitung
Sibelius sperrig und eingängig: das BBC Symphony Orchestra in Zürich
*****
Magnus Lindberg und Anu Komsi beschenken das BBC SO reichlich
****1
Anrührende Herzenswärme: Vilde Frang in Zürich
****1
Blut wird fließen! Elektra bei den Proms
*****
Marie Jacquot serves up super French fare at the BBC Proms
****1
Icelandic fire from Anna Thorvaldsdottir at the BBC Proms
*****
Weitere Kritiken...