ENFRDEES
The classical music website

Ariadne auf Naxos

By , 14 May 2011

The Strauss opera Ariadne auf Naxos was inspired by the Moliere play The
Middle-Class Gentleman. The richest man in Vienna has arranged for two
entertainments--one a serious opera composed by a young man just for the
occasion, and the other an Italian comedy group. He decides at the last minute
to combine the two into one entertainment. If he were a proper gentleman, he
would know better.

Musically it has the same feeling of being a concoction, a shifting landscape.
In Act I all the characters appear as themselves, and sing in a very natural
way, similar to the style of Rosenkavalier. In Act II the comedy troop performs
to dance rhythms while Ariadne and Bacchus are in a serious style probably
closest to Frau ohne Schatten.

The only character prominent in both acts is the soprano Zerbinetta, leader of
the comedy group, sung in a very comic style by Kathleen Kim. She has a major
aria in coloratura style, the only one by Richard Strauss that I am aware of.
Ariadne and her singer self are in both halves, but her part becomes large and
significant in Act II. She is sung by the large and significant Violetta
Urmana. It is a major dramatic soprano role with its own famous aria "Es gibt
ein Reich."

The composer role appears only in Act I. Joyce DiDonato wonderfully expansive
and arrogant portraying this character. She sang fabulously and threw a number
of spactacular temper tantrums.

Bacchus is mostly in the second act and was sung well by the handsome Robert
Dean Smith.

I was less than thrilled by the conducting of Fabio Luisi. The conductor shapes
the musical impression, and often the work lay lifeless.

I'm never quite sure this opera really works, but in any performance I've seen
someone manages to raise the level of excitement and make it live. In this
performance this was Joyce DiDonato.

See full listing
Reviewed at Lincoln Center: Metropolitan Opera House, New York City on 10 May 2011
Strauss R., Ariadne auf Naxos
Metropolitan Opera
Fabio Luisi, Conductor
Violeta Urmana, The Primadonna (Ariadne)
Kathleen Kim, Zerbinetta
Joyce DiDonato, Composer
Robert Dean Smith, The Tenor (Bacchus)
Sir Thomas Allen, Music Master
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay at the Met
***11
Ivo van Hove’s Don Giovanni makes a welcome reappearance at the Met
****1
Cast and orchestra bring down the house in Met’s glowing Turandot
*****
Exciting debut elevates Met Opera The Queen of Spades
***11
John Adams’ Antony and Cleopatra arrives at the Met
****1
Claus Guth directs a tormented, harrowing new Salome at the Met
*****
More reviews...