ENFRDEES
The classical music website

Halloween in February: The Philadelphia Orchestra conjures sorcerers and spells

By , 14 February 2020

Valentine’s Day fell during the most recent run of Philadelphia Orchestra performances, but the subscription program itself harkened back to Halloween. Principal guest conductor Stéphane Denève stacked the first half of the concert — titled “Sorcerers, Spells and Magic” — with music spooky and familiar: the overture to Die Zauberflöte, The Sorcerer’s Apprentice and excerpts from John Williams’ Harry Potter film scores. After intermission came a complete performance of L’Enfant et les sortilèges, with soloists imported from the Metropolitan Opera.

Ravel’s one-act opera sparkled in a semi-staged production by Stephanie Havey that smartly worked within the confines of Verizon Hall. Eschewing props and suggestive costumes, the singers used their bodies and voices to boisterously enact the various creatures and objects tortured by a naughty little boy (called the Child and sung here by Isabel Leonard), who gradually come to life and exact their revenge. In the prelude, Leonard’s Child scurried around the stage, manipulating limbs and displaying wanton disregard for anything but his own amusement.

Clad in pigtails and a Philadelphia Eagles sweatshirt, Leonard suggested youth, if not always boyishness. Her supple mezzo soprano, now darker and heftier than in the early days of her career, occasionally sounded too mature for a role she recorded in 2015. Likewise, Met coloratura Anna Christy’s trill sounded edgier and less secure than when she was a reigning Cunegonde in the dreamlike role of The Princess. Yet both women managed charming moments throughout, and Leonard successfully charted the Child’s evolution from scamp to sweetness in the opera’s final moments.

French tenor Mathias Vidal proved virtuosic as the tongue-twisting, onomatopoeic Monsieur Arithmetic — a personification of the homework ignored by the Child — and contralto Sara Couden brought a recitalist’s feeling for text in several roles, including the Child’s worried Mama. Baritone Yupeng Wang and soprano Meigui Zhang delighted in the sarabande for the reproachful Armchair and Sofa. Denève shaped a rich reading of the score, with lots of little details in the winds, percussion and low strings. The soloists had great partners in the Westminster Symphonic Choir and Philadelphia Boys Choir — the latter particularly effective as Monsieur Arithmetic’s promenading numbers.

Elsewhere, Denève offered intriguing interpretations that didn’t always coalesce. His Mozart had a touch of historical practice, with extreme variations in tempo and noticeable pauses between chords. The result often seemed disjointed, and the blaring, slightly out-of-tune brass frequently drowned out the delicate flutes and oboes. Similarly, the Dukas emerged as a wall of sound, its individual flavors muted. The Harry Potter suite contained some interesting elements — a foreboding celesta and beguiling violin scales played with pinprick delicacy, contrasted by cello pizzicato — but failed to capture my attention for a full fifteen minutes.

There was some romance on the bill at the February 14 matinee performance. During the standard pre-concert announcement, in full view of the audience, trumpet player Anthony Prisk proposed to Julia Li, a member of the first violins. She said yes.


***11
About our star ratings
See full listing
Reviewed at Kimmel Center: Marian Anderson Hall, Philadelphia on 14 February 2020
Mozart, Die Zauberflöte (The Magic Flute), K620: Overture
Dukas, The Sorcerer's Apprentice
Williams, Film music from Harry Potter
Ravel, L'Enfant et les sortilèges
Stéphane Denève, Conductor
Stephanie Havey, Director
Isabel Leonard, The Child
Anna Christy, Princess
Sara Couden, Mother
Mei Gui Zhang, The armchair
Mathias Vidal, Little old man
Yupeng Wang, Chair
Jeffrey R. Smith, Artistic Director
Philadelphia Boys Choir
Westminster Symphonic Choir
The Philadelphia Orchestra
Masked marvels and Venetian mischief: Cavalli at Bayreuth Baroque
*****
Tosca from The Royal Opera: Netrebko returns, with a vengeance
****1
Unseduced: Don Giovanni opens the Budapest Festival Orchestra season
***11
In these sacred halls: a long Sunday at the Enescu Festival
****1
Rossini Renaissance renewed: Ponnelle’s Cenerentola at La Scala
****1
ENO, BBC join forces in stunning Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk
*****
More reviews...